Custom Cookies


Custom Cookie Gallery     Custom Pricing

At The Cakery, our delicious sugar cookies are made from scratch using only the finest ingredients and extracts. Each custom cookie is hand-cut and decorated to order with our signature made-from-scratch buttercream. Custom cookie orders are only available by securing a custom order reservation, so please place your deposit as soon as possible. If the date you are looking for is not available, we still offer frosted round sugar cookies for shorter notice for pre-order in our online store. If you have a nut allergy, please be aware that we use pure almond extract in our buttercream.

Custom Orders Information:

  • Custom cookies may be ordered in any quantity with a minimum of 6.
  • Prices are based on size and intricacy of design.
  • For orders under two dozen, please limit designs to 2-3.
  • Changes to orders must be made at least 3 days in advance.
  • All custom orders must be paid in full at least one week in advance.
  • While we do not individually wrap cookies, cookie bags are available for purchase for $0.35 each. (Just be careful with the buttercream when you wrap!)
©2023. The Cakery Bakery. St. Louis, Missouri